Blog Page 383

KPC CANNOT BE FORCED TO SIGN A NON-EXISTENT EIGHT BILLION MEGA AVIATION OIL TENDER.

0

kip

Lawyer Donald Kipkorir for Kenya Pipeline Company which Public Procurement Board has declines to order to sign mega aviation contract.

BY SAM ALFAN.

The procurement board will not order Kenya Pipeline Company to sign a Sh8 billion contract to construct a fuel depot for aeroplanes at JKIA.

Public Procurement Board would like first to understand why the contract was signed over a year later to an international consortium.

The consortium had been awarded the tender on May 18 2015 but was signed in 2016.

The project was dubbed the Greenfield.

The consortium is made up of four companies; Danish-listed JGH Marine and a subsidiary of the China National Petroleum Corporation, Northeastern refining and Chemical Engineering Company.

Other firms in the consortium are Western Marine Services and Pride Enterprises.

Civicon Limited and the consortium participated in the November 2014 open tender.

Through Lawyer Donald Kipkorir, Kenya Pipeline Company, the procuring entity however opposed the request for review.

KPC stated that the request was frivolous, vexatious and an abuse of process of the board.

Mr Kipkorir submitted that the applicant could not force Kenya Pipeline to sign a contract for a project that no longer existed.

The land where the development was to be executed is owned by the Kenya Airways Authority which cancelled the Greenfield project.

Mr Kipkorir said that it then follows that the tender could not be performed since the owner of the land was not willing to go on with the parent project.

The Board further set aside the Kenya Pipeline decision terminating the procurement process as communicated to the international consortium’s letter dated August 24 this year.

Immediately after award, one of the unsuccessful bidders M/s Civicon limited instituted a request for review which upon consideration directed that the tender be awarded to Civicon limited.

The current applicant-the International consortium which was the successful bidder was dissatisfied with the reviews board’s decision and instituted a case at the high court which quashed the board’s earlier decision and remitted the request for review back to the board for re-hearing and for final determination.

DPP APPEALS DECISION TO ACQUIT PARLIAMENT STAFF.

0

IMG_20160906_215810

Seven parliament staff before trial court at Milimani law court.

BY SAM ALFAN.

Director of Public Prosecution Keriako Tobiko will challenge a decision releasing senior officials working in Parliament.

He moved to the High Court questioning the move by Nairobi Chief Magistrate Daniel Ogembo who ordered that their charge be struck out, they be released even without hearing a single witness.

CM Ogembo based his decision on alleged violation of the accused persons’ right to a fair trial under Article 50 of the Constitution.

The prosecution however wants the High Court to revise and set aside the said order and direct that the matter proceeds to a full hearing.

DPP instituted criminal proceedings against the accused persons on November10 2015 blaming them for conspiring to commit a felony among others charges.

They all pleaded not guilty.

The court proceeded to release the accused persons on a bond of Sh1 million and one surety of a similar amount or in the alternative a cash bail of Sh300, 000.

Several documents could not be availed by the parliament because of their nature of confidentiality.

According to the prosecutor the documents the accused were demanding were classified and contained information that if leaked to the public would expose Members of Parliament dealings and be a matter of national security.

The prosecutor also informed the court that his case was not relying on the said documents to prove his case and that they were in safe custody of the Parliamentary Service Commission.

“The Chief Magistrate has no powers to purport to interpret the Constitution as he did in dismissing the charges citing violation of the accused person’s right to a fair trial since he is not a Judge. The Prosecution supplied all the witness statements and documentary exhibits it intended to rely upon during the trial,” he said.

He also accused CM Ogembo of being unfair and biased. “He never accorded the complainant an opportunity to be heard.”

Further, the Ruling in question undermines the doctrine of separation of powers and specifically the power of the Director of Public Prosecutions to control criminal Proceedings, he argued.

The DPP also urged the court to call for and examine the record in the aforesaid proceedings so as to satisfy itself and pronounce itself on the legality or propriety of the findings and orders as well as the regularity of the proceedings giving rise to the suit.

 

MACHAKOS GOVERNOR ALFRED MUTUA FALLS IN COURT BID.

0

img_20160923_210801

Machakos Governor Dr Alfred Mutua who is expected to face charge’s over alleged illegal procurement.

BY SAM ALFAN.

The High Court has given a green for Machakos Governor Dr Alfred Mutua to be charged over alleged illegal procurement.

The court has dismissed a suit where Governor Mutua sought to block his prosecution over the purchase of motor vehicles.

His right to information, the court said was not violated as he was informed of the nature and scope of the investigation.

“The buck stops with the Governor in the management of County,” the court ruled.

High court judge Edward Muriithi said that issues raised in the petition by the governor can be determined by the trial court which would be properly seized of the facts and all the evidence against him.

“I do not see any merit in the petition……..I shall dismiss the petition with an order that each party should bear its cost,” the judge said.

Governor Mutua had told the court that the decision to procure motor vehicles was approved by the County Assembly on 30th July 2013 and therefore the decision to prosecute him is unreasonable and not proportional adding that it amounts to an abuse of the court process.

He argued that he should not be questioned on matters of implementation of policies as that is the duty of the county’s accounting officer.

EACC however dismissed claims by the governor that the acquisition of the motor vehicles did not abide with any statutory procurement methods adding that Mutua not only initiated the purchase of the vehicles but the vehicles were sourced and the pricing settled by him before the matter was placed before the tender committee.

“Evidence gathered indicated that the petitioner violated the law and hence the charges intended to be preferred against him,”EACC argued.

NAIROBI SENATOR MIKE SONKO HAS TO PRODUCE MRC LEADER BY NOVEMBER.

0

fb_img_1474639552601
Nairobi Senator Mike Sonko at Mombasa Law Courts.
BY SAM ALFAN.

Nairobi Senator Mike Sonko has two months to produce MRC leader Omar Mwamnuadzi.

The senator however asked for more time to find out Mwamnuadzi’s whereabouts when he appeared before chief magistrate Daniel Ogoti on Friday.

The senator had deposited three title deeds and assured court that he would ensure the leader will appear in court.

He has missed sessions at Mombasa and Kwale courts.

He and nine others were accused of being members of an outlawed group.

Mwamnuadzi was also accused, alongside his wife Maimuna Hamisi, of having weapons including firearms.

They are also facing two counts of incitement to violence and having material used in witchcraft.

“I pledge to make sure the accused appears before this court on the date that will be decided,” he had affirmed.

He said that he was aware of the repercussions of the accused’s absence from court, including losing his property.

Sonko said he will discuss the matter with the MRC leader’s wife and children who were in court.

He said he last heard from Mwamnuadzi when he fell sick and was admitted at Coast Provincial General Hospital.

But the prosecution noted hospital documents presented in court were fake and that Mwamnuadzi had intentionally skipped court.

The Senator accused the prosecution of delaying the case causing some of the accused to miss proceedings.

A warrant was also issued for the arrest of Juma Mwakusema who did not attend court.

Proceedings resume November 23.

DISGRUNTLED JUDGE TO APPEAL TRIBUNAL DECISION SENDING HIM HOME.

0

2016-09-22_15-16-39
Suspended High Court judge Joseph Mutava lawyer Phillip Nyachoti addressing journalists in his Chambers at museum hill in Nairobi on Thursday September 22,2016.
BY SAM ALFAN .

High Court judge Joseph Mutava will appeal the findings of a tribunal that recommended his removal.

Through his lawyer Phillip Nyachoti, the judge said the tribunal, chaired by Appellate Judge David Maraga, was wrong to use recanted evidence.

“It is strange for the tribunal to base its report on complaints which were all withdrawn,” said Mr Nyachoti on Thursday.

The tribunal on Wednesday found Justice Mutava guilty of allocating himself a file on a case involving Goldenberg architect Kamlesh Pattni without the knowledge of the duty judge.

In recommendations handed to President Uhuru Kenyatta, the tribunal said it had established as valid three complaints against the judge.

In his final submissions, Judge Mutava said that the allegations of misconduct were not substantiated and indeed lacked sufficient gravity to warrant his removal.

He also wanted his suspension lifted so he can resume duty immediately.

The judge had been suspended in May 2013 on the recommendation of the Judicial Service Commission.

The cases that brought the judge’s career down involved Businessman Kamlesh Pattni and Goldenberg, while a second case was that he interfered with the ruling of another judge by making persistent inquiries in a manner that went beyond ordinary judicial curiosity and even attempted to influence the outcome of the ruling.

The third claim was that he mishandled a dispute between the Ministry of Industrialization and the East African Portland Cement Company by issuing contradicting orders.

However, the three complaints by Lawyer Fred Ngatia, Nelson Havi Advocate’s client and Rose Mbithe which necessitated the formation of the Tribunal were withdrawn.

“A matter which has been withdrawn is in law wholly and fully retracted and cannot exist in any form or shape and that includes the substratum that led to the formation of this Honorable Tribunal,” the judge told the tribunal.

NEW CJ NOMINATED; PRESIDENT KENYATTA TO APPROVE OR REJECT.

0

fb_img_1474542772974

Court of Appeal Judge David Maraga who has been nominated to succeed Chief Justice Willy Mutunga.

BY SAM ALFAN.

Court of Appeal Judge David Maraga has be nominated to succeed Chief Justice Willy Mutunga.

Justice Maraga, 65, will take over from Willy Mutunga, who retired in June 2016 if his nomination is approved by President Uhuru Kenyatta and the National Assembly.

The Judicial Service Commission announced on Thursday that the CJ will assume office with immediate effect.

He was among 11 judges earlier shortlisted by the Judicial Service Commission.

During the interviews, judge Maraga found himself at pains to demonstrate his expertise in applying the law in conflicting suits.

Attorney General Prof Githu Muigai, one of the panelists, put him to task, seeking to know how he would pass judgment in suits where two or several laws were at conflict.

He used a case study of a surrogate mother who decided not to give a child to its separated biological parents, who were both seeking custody.

Judge Maraga admitted that the question was tricky but answered: “In this scenario, the child’s interest is paramount.”

MOSES KURIA WAS CHIEF ARCHITECT OF AN ASSASSINATION PLOT ON UON VICE CHANCELLOR, COURT TOLD.

0

img_20160921_193937
University of Nairobi security Chief Francis Makau testifying at Nairobi Court on Wednesday September 21,2016.

BY NAIROBI TIMES CORRESPONDENT.

Gatundu South MP Moses Kuria was chief to a group that planned the assassination of University of Nairobi Vice Chancellor.

A court also heard that he attended several meetings in which plans were hatched to eliminate Prof Peter Mbithi.

The group further planned how they would cripple  operations at University.

A witness, testifying under oath said he received information that meetings had been taking place to strategies how to eliminate the VC.

“The informant said a meeting took place at Manga Hotel in Limuru attended by Gatundu South MP Moses Kuria and student leaders who were then jostling for posts in SONU,” he said.

He was testifying in a case where Wyclif Ochieng, the accused had implicated the institution’s sacked  Deputy Vice-Chancellor of Administration and Finance Prof Bernard Njoroge in the scheme.

Wyclif Ochieng with giving false information at Milimani law court during the hearing of the case.
Wyclif Ochieng with giving false information at Milimani law court during the hearing of the case.

He was charged with giving false information.

The witness said a decision was made to engage senior police officers in the matter after Mr Ochieng dropped names of “some VIPs in relation to the planned murder.”

UON security Chief Mr Francis Makau told the court that the gravity of the matter and the people mentioned drove them to involve a senior police officer at the county command.

“I felt it should be handled by senior police officers as it involved a death threat and disruption of learning at the campus,” he said.

Lawyer Edward Oonge also wanted the witness to confirm whether they knew a student leader named Mike Jacobs who allegedly recruited Mr Ochieng, of which they answered in the affirmative stating that he was one of the contestants in the SONU elections.

In an affidavit sworn on May 21 Ochieng states that he attended a series of meetings where the plot was being hatched and that he was a member of a gang that had also infiltrated the institution to cause chaos during last years SONU elections that turned chaotic prompting the university to be closed.

He said that he later developed cold feet when the assassination plot was unveiled.

“Towards the end of January 2016, I was invited to attend a meeting at a Nairobi hotel with the financiers,” Mr Ochieng’s affidavit reads.

He states that a politician(Kuria) told a Mr Bongo “to get two Probox vehicles for the mission to kill Prof Mbithi.”

Proceedings resume December 6.

EX-CS ANN WAIGURU IN HOT SOUP FOR COMMENTING ON NYS PROSECUTIONS.

0

waiguru100614

Former Devolution CSMs Waiguru whe eight nys suspects want to be stopped from making any comments about the ongoing case.

BY SAM ALFAN.

Former Devolution Cabinet Secretary Ann Waiguru is on the receiving end after suspects in the Sh791 National Youth Service scam asked her to keep off their case.

The eight also want Ms Waiguru to stop making any comments about the ongoing case.

They have been charged with money laundering.

Lawyer Maina Wachira for John Kinuthia and Paul Van Dame urged the court to bar Waiguru from commenting on the matter completely since it is prejudicial to their clients.

They say Waiguru has been making endless trips to media houses continually making comments exonerating her at the expense of the suspects.

They additionally want the Public Accounts Committee barred from summoning any of the accused.

Call and letters have been dispatched by from the committee summoning them to appear before it on various dates.

Director of Public Prosecution Keriako Tobiko cautioned that he could not speak on behalf of the ex-CS saying she is no longer a public officer or a witness in the case and as such if the court deems it necessary should serve her with summons like any other ordinary Kenyan.

The court has also declined to expunge Charity Gethi from the trial.

Senior Principal Magistrate Martha Mutuku decline the application citing endless time by accused person to appears in court.

Josephine Kabura and Ben Gethi appeared before Nairobi chief magistrate Daniel Ogembo alongside six others on Monday.

They denied 15 counts of money laundering and were released on Sh300,000 cash bail or Sh1 million bond each.

The eight were accused of colluding to wire the amount from NYS coffers and using part of it to purchase property through phony companies.

They allegedly committed the offences between December 1, 2014 and March 2015.

Gethi’s mother Charity, his sister Jedida Wangari and one other suspect did not appear in court.

The magistrate heard that Charity was admitted at Melchizedek Hospital in Nairobi. He issued warrants for the arrest of the two.

The 11 suspects were to answer to the charges in February but were yet to following multiple applications seeking to block their prosecution.

Proceedings resume a day before end month.

MUDAVADI SAYS ANGLO-LEASING CONTRACTS WERE AS CLEAR AS THE SKY.

0

img_20160921_194106
Amani National Congress leader Musalia Mudavadi looking at a documents he was should during the hearing Anglo-leasing case at Nairobi Anti-corruption Court on Wednesday September 21,2016.
BY NAIROBI CORRESPONDENT.

Amani National Congress leader Musalia Mudavadi has told the anti-corruption court that his former colleagues in government are not guilty of stealing Anglo-leasing money.

The money that the government lost with the infamous Anglo-leasing scandal was Sh10 billion.

Mr Mudavadi who at the time was the Transport and Infrastructure Minister took the witness stand in the case involving former Finance Minister and now Kisii County Senator Chris Obure, former Postmaster General Francis Chahonyo, former Financial Secretary Samuel Bundotich and former Permanent Secretary Sammy Kyungu.

During cross-examination by defense lawyers Kioko Kilukumi and Chacha Odera, Mudavadi told the anti-corruption court that “based on all the documentation one cannot say their actions were arbitrary as the laid down procedures were followed.”

The ex- minister said the four did not make a personal decision in awarding the contracts as they were satisfied with the necessary information and documentation required before doing so.

“Minister Obure at the time, authorised payment after being satisfied with information he had sought from my Ministry and cannot therefore be said  to have  acted arbitrarily,’’ he added.

The former senior government officials have since denied conspiring to defraud the government of Sh10 billion by awarding the Anglo-Leasing contracts.

The contracts were entered between the Government of Kenya and two US companies for the supply of internet services in 2002.

He said that he never interacted with Spacenet and Mercantile companies but admitted to signing letters seeking support from the Ministry of Finance after he received information that the Postal Corporation, a parastatal under his Ministry required new technology to improve its services.

Chahonyo and Kyungu are alleged to have initiated the procurement in a network of operations executed between March and July 2002 for which Obure authorised the payments while Bundotich made the payments.

Obure faces two counts of abuse of office and breach of trust by authorising the Ministry of Transport to directly procure VSAT equipment from Spacenet Inc for the Postal Corporation of Kenya without following procurement procedures.

The trial was adjourned to November when Senator Amos Wako is expected to testify.

KIDERO SACKED COUNTY EXECUTIVE FOR GOING TO CHURCH WITH EX-CS WAIGURU; COURT ORDERS A HANDSOME COMPENSATION.

0

img_20160921_194319
Former Nairobi County county executives Mr Evans Ondieki at Milimani Law alCourt on Wednesday September 21,2016.
BY THOMAS KARIUKI.

Nairobi County Governor Dr Evans Kidero will now pay one of his former county executives Mr Evans Ondieki a whooping Sh8.8 million for unlawful dismissal.

In a consent entered on behalf of the governor by his lawyer Professor Tom Ojienda and dated August 22 2016, Dr Kidero says he will comply with a court decision that ordered Mr Ondieki be compensated.

The award was issued on August 5 2016 by the Employment and Labour Relation court which included unpaid salaries, gratuity and cost of the suit.

Before his dismissal, Mr Ondieki served as the Environment Executive for Nairobi County.

Justice Nduma Nderi of the Labour Court quashed Kidero’s decision removing Ondieki from office saying it was done in an impervious manner.

The judge said that Governor Kidero was unreasonable and petty in sacking Ondieki on the basis that he attended a church service alongside former Devolution CS Anne Waiguru.

However, Judge Nderi did not see the need to direct the county to rehire Ondieki since he had not asked to be reinstated.

The county government has 30 days to compute the award and file the same for consideration by the court.

Mr Ondieki told the court that his sacking was instigated by malice and political whims.

He claimed he was fired for supporting Waiguru and Dagoretti South MP Dennis Waweru.

On January 26, days after reshuffling his government Kidero appointed Urban Renewals and Housing CEC Tom Odongo to replace Ondieki in acting capacity.

Governor Kidero said the decision was aimed at ensuring efficient service delivery to Nairobians.